Getting it together?

Getting it together?

An essay about Togetherness season 1  that I wrote a few months ago for something or other and which I’ve decided to re-home here. I really really liked it, and although this is about its first run, its second has been equally worth watching.

‘They seem like they’re getting there.’

Modern suburbia has never felt as stifling as it does in Mark and Jay Duplass’ Togetherness. The HBO series aired in the US at the beginning of 2015, and is a tight and poignant look at the roadblocks which undermine, perhaps fatally, our familial relationships.

So far, so much like any of a raft of recent American comedy-dramas, not least Lena Dunham’s own HBO vehicle Girls. (Dunham shares a long history with the Duplasses, too.) (Note: Amusingly, this was written before Netflix gave us Flaked, Love, or Master of None.) However in detailing the failing sexual chemistry and road-to-nowhere marriage of Mark Duplass’ Brett and the wonderful Melanie Lynskey’s Michelle, the series begins to do more than the likes of Girls, it manages to delve artfully into the psychological aspects of that age-old dream of many a couple: growing old together. For Brett and Michelle it has gradually become very hard indeed.

Steve Zissis as Brett’s best friend and wannabe actor Alex and Michelle’s sister Tina, played in equal parts manic and subdued by Amanda Peet, round out the show’s foursome of leads, with the latter couple’s romantic tension allowing Togetherness to play two relationships at entirely different stages against each other. Not that Alex and Tina are in a relationship, nor that a tired Will They/Won’t They dominated their storylines either. Instead they serve as more fleshed-out examples of the sublimated failings Brett and Michelle feel trapped by, too. Alex flailing for success that matches his own conception of himself—he’s a leading man not a chubby, funny sidekick— Tina just flailing.

Both are, in a convenient manner which reminds us that Togetherness is supposed to be a sitcom, staying at Brett and Michelle’s family home for the duration of the series. How they negotiate both this and a shared feeling of failure plays out alongside the show’s central marriage.

In truth Togetherness excels at depicting the dreary not-at-all-like-the-movies slice of American life once colonised exclusively by short story writers like Raymond Carver or Tobias Wolff. The Duplass brothers brought the traumas of the everyday— domestic boredom and unfulfilled hopes, joblessness, marital unhappiness, motherhood— to HBO. To quote the critic David Means on Carver, Togetherness offers ‘a sliver of some wider existence’. With help from Zissis who shares a creator credit, Duplass and Duplass tell the sort of story that is in itself a critique of more ornately plotted, structurally conceited sitcoms. Togetherness is about actual real life, they’re telling us, and that real life can be as compelling and moving as elaborate meet-cutes and seeing the same five people in a bar for ten years straight.

Instead Togetherness feels like a natural progression for the Duplass brothers. Known as pioneers in the so-called ‘Mumblecore’ indie movie scene, the stilted, honest dialogue between Brett and Michelle, Alex and Tina is perhaps the most obvious inherited trait. Films such as Safety Not Guaranteed, Hannah Takes the Stairs, and Your Sister’s Sister wedded themselves to a knowingly uncinematic manner, eschewing stylised plot or dialogue. Inability to communicate with those we care about became the central mumblecore ‘theme’, and Togetherness takes this conceit and, profoundly, runs with it. The series is full of “y’know”s, “dunno”s, “kinda”s and other carefully observed verbal signs of anxiety and confusion; this is about a critical lack of articulation. Not for nothing do the outsiders played by John Ortiz and Mary Steenburgen who Brett and Michelle respectively meet see them much more conversationally fluent.

At times though, Togetherness ditches the hyperrealism and ventures into trippy fantasy, and these elements are perhaps less well-handled than the show’s quieter moments, but the excursions Brett takes with self-avowedly “weird” Linda during episodes six and seven allow the Duplass brothers to engage with the crippling claustrophobia of the too-full home at Togetherness’ heart. This aspect of the plot could, bizarrely be described by saying that Brett finds a hippy hiding in a bush who helps give his self-brutalising anxiety an outlet. Quite literally, in one scene Mark Duplass and the delicately off-kilter Mary Steenburgen spend a magic mushroom-induced moment screaming into the Californian wilderness. If that sounds like a scene from a different television show, it is because it feels that way. Togetherness calculatedly transforms from an awkward and grindingly intimate piece into something which feels briefly like an agoraphobic’s worst nightmare. For Brett though, this utter freedom is necessary, and the production team don’t shy away from presenting what comes perilously close to a full-blown breakdown.

The drug induced mania then reaches its climax in devastating fashion, with Mark Duplass at his quiet best returning to his character’s family home wearing a too-short ladies dressing gown that’s entirely inappropriate for the children’s party he finds himself in the middle of. The final episode sees Brett on a more even keel, mostly thanks to touching moments of connection with his five-year old daughter, and an about-to-be-successful Alex, but the disjunction between Brett and his wife will remain, a poignant and truthful-to-life barrier to happiness.

And on the other side of this marital equation Lynskey shines. As vibrant as Zizzis, Dupass, and Peet are, she is the real star of Togetherness. Facially her ability to express how utterly adrift she feels from her husband is time and again the most haunting aspect of this show, particularly as the series draws to a close and her interactions, and instant chemistry with the dashing charter-school pioneer David begins to show. Rarely does fiction —on TV, film or in books— present impending adultery as so understandable.

From being caught during an awkward attempt at Fifty Shades-inspired masturbation, complete with repurposed clothes pegs as nipple clamps to her painfully rebuffed go at a little BDSM experimentation with her husband, scenes that could be cheaply salacious and erotic, are instead undercut by a subtle but extreme despair. Lynskey’s Michelle is wounded by a certain dreary monotony, by having given up her life for her family and seeing herself growing older but no happier. In her early-to-mid thirties she’s become all but sexually incompatible with a husband who has begun to spin off into his own confused orbit. An early episode sees her blow-off a glitzy engagement (Brett works as a sound engineer on a film) to just wander. Minutes later she ends up giving a group of teenagers cigarettes and revelling in the fact that they see her a sexy older woman, revelling in being found interesting and not being weighed down by her husband or family.

The final episode of the show’s first run takes pains to demonstrate that this is no staid rom-com. As James Blake’s haunting ‘The Wilhelm Scream’ lets us know that Michelle, having saved the charter school project is “falling”, the show-runners tease the viewer with a pair of classic tropes, the timely arrival and the declaration of love. In Togetherness though, neither work, and Alex will make peace with his acting success rather than his romantic glory, while a second series will have to handle a whole barrow of unanswered questions about Brett and Michelle. The Duplasses and Zissis have not made this easy for their audience, but my god they’ve made it real.

A few months before Togetherness premiered, Richard Linklater’s Boyhood was the talk of the entertainment world with it documentary-esque portrayal of the trials and tribulations which make up ordinary life. Togetherness does something similar but without the fad of having filmed for twelve years. Life doesn’t necessarily lend itself to what we usually conceive of ‘drama’ or ‘plot’, but if you go looking for poignancy and humour in the banal and the domestic, plot and drama can make themselves known. This is the thesis at the heart of Togetherness, and it is one that the show makes good on. It illustrates the often painful banality of normal life.

A couple has come apart at the seams, and they explain the show pretty well themselves: Michelle’s “what is going on with you? What is going on?” finds Brett in his incongruent —and to her offensive— dressing gown reply, “You were having a great time, until I turned up.” They are an example of the opposite of togetherness, exemplary of the perils of not working at one’s domestic life and falling into stagnant patterns instead. Togetherness is tragicomedy really, an exploration of how humans can possibly survive bound too-tightly to another. Tina is this idea taken to a logical conclusion too, sublimating herself in a loveless relationship because she can’t face the risk of someone getting too close, and in this way her character is the saddest, especially in a finale which expresses hope for each of the other leads.

A TV show about an unyielding slide towards adultery, played out largely in quiet conversations and with subtle musical cues (James Blake excepted) shouldn’t have worked. However Togetherness pulls together the threads of the Duplass brother’s careers alongside some revelatory performances from Lynskey and Zissis to wonderful effect. This subtle, mournful show captures life’s nasty little ironies like nothing I can remember.

A clean-ish slate

There was an unpublished blog-post lurking in the drafts section of this site from a few years ago called ‘Greek Tragedy and Fifty Shades of Andrea Pirlo’. Yes, I am that much of an arsehole.

That’s just one of 29 unpublished drafts metaphorically lying around though, which suggests that I’ve really struggled to follow through on the numerous promises made in old posts (to myself, more than anyone) to write here regularly. So there’s a new plan.

First of all, I’m going to delete all of those drafts. They haven’t all got rubbish titles, but they are, almost without exception, the dreary detritus of an emotionally constipated student’s mind. And after that rather cathartic experience I’m hoping to write here sometimes. That’s it. No vows or giant symbolic headstones, I just might write things occasionally. It seems to be back in. 

Maybe this daftly-titled blog (thanks 17 year old me) will be a fun place to detail the woes of a faintly directionless grad, who knows?

Newcastle United and me: a testing relationship

Newcastle United and me: a testing relationship

So I’ve resurrected the old blog to talk about football.

—————————-

Never has an impending World Cup felt so important. Not because of the teams playing, not because of the players, or even the location – spectacular as it is. No, I am desperate to immerse myself in the World Cup because it will hopefully remind me why I love football – you see the last 18 months of watching Newcastle United have dulled my senses, I love football, but sometimes it definitely hasn’t felt like that.

It is not simply that the football club I have always supported have been terrible – they have been at times, but I can take that – the issue is instead the atmosphere around the club. Quite simply, as the final day implosion at Liverpool showed, there is something toxic at the heart of the Gallowgate.

I am not one to call blindly for new signings, but it is an awfully long time since Newcastle United made a permanent acquisition, and on a superficial level, this exemplifies the lack of ambition around the club – everything is decided on the basis of month-to-month profits, if we can get by with a cheap Loïc Remy for a year and then find a similar replacement, why not? There is no interest in any long-term plan to improve as a team, there is no interest in retaining what is an almost uniquely personal position in the lives of 50,000 fans, and there is no interest in living up to the best legacies of the past.

A few years ago Lee Bowyer and Kieron Dyer infamously fought on the Villa Park pitch in black and white colours, as a young teen I didn’t imagine that it would be easy for the actions of those representing NUFC to become more of an embarrassment. This last season has blown that farce out of the water.

There was the club’s dictatorial refusal to deal with the local press, Alan Pardew’s much publicized head-butt, Hatem Ben Arfa’s bizarre passive aggression on Instagram, Steven Taylor’s racist tweet, and no doubt several other unedifying incidents which I have banished from memory. All of these things have made me wonder how easy it would be to forget where I was brought up and move on from this godforsaken football club, but that’s not going to happen. Instead I’ll keep watching through my fingers and hope that I eventually am able to stop justifying a litany of disasters.

All of the off-field chaos has served to brutally underline the most underwhelming of seasons on the pitch. A decent start was enough for seemingly everyone involved with the football club. Form since Christmas has been abysmal, and the apparent lack of interest in winning games felt like a betrayal of why we care about football.

I’m tired of making unending lists of the problems which coalesce around St James’ Park like the acrid smoke which accompanies the entrance of a pantomime villain, but the fundamental problem is one of inertia – I simply don’t see things changing, for the next however many years the management of the football club are happy to just keep ticking over; start the season well enough to avoid a relegation melee and then just cruise to the end of the season, try to keep the better players fit in case a more ambitious club comes calling.

It’s viscerally sad.

Newcastle United are always going to be my team, that’s just the way it is, but it would be nice for them to act a little bit more like they care about that fact. This coming Summer may see a change of direction (which would I suppose simply be any direction). It would be nice to have it look like more than one or two players give a fuck about the city; it would be nice to see players joining with the intention of becoming Newcastle United heroes rather than just using the club as a metaphorical showroom; above all though, I don’t want to feel as disconcertingly empty as I did when watching Shola Ameobi talk his way into a red card ever again.

It’s not about good football or bad football, it is about paying attention to what makes a football club worthwhile. When the club banned the Evening Chronicle from media engagements, the Chronicle used Sir Bobby Robson’s poignant ‘what is a club?’ quote on an evocative front page, and I enjoyed the fact that I had mentioned that quote earlier in the week. Whatever else you may say about Sir Bobby Robson, he made Newcastle United a club I could say I supported without cringing, and the quote, below, sums up why I feel so disheartened right now.

“What is a club in any case?

Not the buildings or the directors or the people who are paid to represent it.

It’s not the television contracts, get-out clauses, marketing departments or executive boxes.
It’s the noise, the passion, the feeling of belonging, the pride in your city.
It’s a small boy clambering up stadium steps for the very first time, gripping his father’s hand, gawping at that hallowed stretch of turf beneath him and, without being able to do a thing about it, falling in love.”

Because I just can’t seem to write during term-time.

Because I just can’t seem to write during term-time.

It’s twenty past one on a Monday morning. Can’t you tell I’m a student?

The title of this blog isn’t strictly true, I’ve written far too much about some things this autumn, but it is extremely factual when it comes to Obfuscatory Nonsense. You see it seems that whenever I get the urge to write something it’s 4am and I’m mid-essay and it’s the most counterproductive thing in the world.

So now I have a bit of respite from the essays, I have decided to just type away, and see which strange avenues I explore.

————————–

It’s easy to lose yourself to being busy. Balancing mobile phone alarms has become my trade. The snooze function is akin to the big boss on an old video game. Spotify has found a new use as a timepiece – for time is now judged in songs, not minutes. Bikes are miraculous inventions, but they overestimate the effort required in your legs. And then a late night walk home can be a wonderful way to switch off – even as you are simultaneously wishing to not have to walk anywhere.

What I am trying to convey, I suppose, is simply how hectic my life seems to have been this term. I don’t think it has been, really. It is not as if life has ever seriously threatened to not fit into the minutes as they fly by. It does seem that the contrast between how ‘on the go’ and purposeful I’ve felt during term, and the bizarre lull which seemed to settle around Oxford as night fell on Friday of 8th week, must be telling. I have been able to go food shopping with more than just the current evening in mind, aimless walking is allowed again, and writing for pleasure seems somewhat palatable.

…which bring us to now. Let’s rewind a little;  it is getting towards that mythical two o’clock moment –  mythical because I tend to think that 0200hours is the line between late-night, and early morning – and I’m doing what I end up doing every term break: Watching film after film and being inspired by at least every other offering, potentially every other scene.

I spent two hours earlier in the week watching one about drinking – it felt appropriate for this, the fag-end of term. It was a film I had actually never heard of until about 25 minutes before I began to watch. Called ‘Drinking Buddies’, and starring Olivia Wilde, Jake Johnson – of New Girl fame – and Anna Kendrick, it was a lo-fi quite romantic comedy. But that undersells it slightly, because in reality it was a film about how a preponderance of alcohol, fuzzes the way we feel about things, and people of course. The main thing I admired about it was definitely Johnson’s beard, but otherwise a film which decides to actually be a bit interesting with the whole ‘rom-com’ genre was a nice change.

Since then I have watched the first Hunger Games movie, Anchorman, half of Annie Hall, the third Harry Potter film, Johnny English, and Adventureland – it has been a fun and varied week all told.

All of those are good films, a couple might even be great. The first in that list explained to me quite why everyone thought Jennifer Lawrence was ace before Silver Linings Playbook. The second reminded me why I’m terrified about the sequel (no way can they match the original…). The third, although it remained unfinished thanks to the vagaries of my sleeping pattern, made me smile an awful lot and led me to spend too long browsing Woody Allen-style glasses. Numbers four and five both took me back a little: Harry Potter, as is discussed elsewhere on this blog, is simply the biggest touchstone in my childhood, whilst Rowan Atkinson taking on the John Malkovich’s fabulous French accent did what it always does and made me giggle and really want to watch an old Bond film.The final film pointed out something quite pertinent to me (in addition to the fact that Kristen Stewart can actually sort-of act): it suggestively hinted that daft things happen when you go in search of a plot.

On a related note, the real lesson that each of those films has taught me is thus: The world in which they take place is ever so slightly misaligned with our – actual – world. The way in which Drinking Buddies subverts a couple of conventions (I won’t say how) is probably as close as any recent film has got to fitting the metaphorical tracing paper on top of dodgy sketch that is reality. Films shouldn’t be about reality though, at least not as a rule (because who in their right mind would watch a film about me writing this, at two o’clock in the morning and wearing a stupid hat?), but that doesn’t stop the self-reflexive way in which reality tries to be like films.

(If the person alluded to in the brackets directly above is you, please let me know, you either need some serious help, or you’re perfect; it really could go either way.)

So, I think I have worked out that that is what I love about films, and all the other forms of fiction we have – there’s this bizarre relationship going on which makes us watch things, and read things, and care about those things.

Raise your glass to fantasy then, the subtle kind, just as much as the kind which has dragons.

Ranting and raving: A year.

Ranting and raving: A year.

Staring at the walls of the bedroom that I’ve flat-out refused to give up for as long as I can remember – it is the biggest – and reflecting on the last year is slightly harder than I had expected it to be. It’s been a year that has resisted labelling. As if it were some suspicious insect which just could be a spider if I was to tilt my head in the correct direction, I’ve found myself unsure quite how to pin-down quite what has been going on during a span of time which has taken me from the achingly familiar to the disconcertingly well-known.

Amusingly – to my no doubt shellshocked ‘fresher’ brain at least -I spent most of Christmas stuck with the word ‘crazy’. ‘Mental’ occasionally forced its way in, but – apart from being examples of a kind of stigmatisation of mental illness which I’d really rather didn’t come from my mouth – neither term tells anyone anything about what I’ve been up to.

The fact that I’ve written about one and a half things on here didn’t help, either.

In truth, it’s been a year spent receptively. Living in a new city is strange, and it is something which threatens to dismember you fairly often. Apart from anything things like ‘not losing your accent’ – however inconspicuous mine is – become ridiculously important. It’s impossible to be aloof from your circumstances though, and a year down the line I know I’m an older person, with an ever-so-slightly altered perspective.

Oxford’s great. If I were to pick a city to influence the way I think, I don’t think I’d have many other options. From the insanity of Mayday with its morris dancers and extreme tiredness, to the way in which the last day of exams sapped my will to do anything, the city and the university were both incredibly (pretentiously) present. It’s  place full of the most bizarre kind of history, and then when I remember that Exeter College itself derives a great deal of its infamy from fictional (Morse, Pullman, Bennett) sources, I get oh-so drawn into the grand narrative of the place.

As I say, it’ s been a good year. My top personal reflections include the disappointing fact that University puts a strain on your waistline – I have a particularly love/hate kinda relationship with the infamous Hassan’s – and the really quite worrying fact that I strangely like how much I resemble a shit Hollywood villain when I’m lazy enough to allow the pathetic beginnings of  a moustache to become unchecked. (I know it’s not good, I really know.)

This has been strangely hard to write. The majority of it came when I was really quite drunk, and I’ve only edited that bit slightly. That’s probably for the best though. I was never sure whether I wanted to, or how I would, cover ‘Oxford’ on here. And this is probably the only effort I’m going to make to do so. Directly, anyway.

Instead, I’m just gonna try and write stuff. Working title might well include frequent self-deprecating references to myself as a ‘workshy layabout who likes the sound of his own voice’.

I actually really think I might keep this promise to write more on here, too.

When you’re compelled to write at least an essay a week, writing for pleasure becomes ever less attractive. It’s a pathetic cop-out, I know. And maybe on some level you could say I’ve been a little nervous of exposing my blog-self to people who’ve not really had the chance to laugh at me yet, but when I look back at all the things that I’ve wanted to write about but haven’t, I really quite detest my own inactivity.

So here we are. In actual fact, right now I feel as though there are too many things that I want to write about: From the – to this Northerner – claustrophobic experience of getting a bus across London, to finding a surprising degree of calm in a convenient little Italian restaurant. There’s also been skiing, where it  hit me how a circle of Alps can blind you from reality a little too well, not to mention Oxford itself, which, for all the writers and thinkers it has inspired, hasn’t spurred me towards an outbreak of productivity, at least not on here. That’s not to say that an awful lot of note-worthy things haven’t occurred, t’s a city filled with bizarre characters who are all quite definitely worth relating someday -with their names and identities changed, of course!

An accidental hiatus, however, does achieve some things. Apart from anything, I think there’s a moderate-to-good chance that I’m now a better writer than I was six months ago… (I can hope anyway right?)

—

The plan is to up the stakes I think. Stay tuned.

Rafa – A bit of a love letter.

Rafa – A bit of a love letter.

I’ve realised that it’s a bloody long while since I’ve posted anything on here – since the start of university in fact – so I decided to put what follows up. It’s something that I wrote for somewhere else towards the end of term.

So, this was first seen in one of the late-November print editions of the Cherwell (http://www.cherwell.org/), and as such it’s fairly formal. I’ve always really liked Rafael Nadal though. (Also, for the record this is pre-editor, as I’ve not actually seen the polished result, so all my IP except for the obvious twitter stuff…)

——————————————————————————————————————————————–

It’s been an ominous six months for tennis fans. This is slightly crazy thing to say though I suppose, amongst Andy Murray’s breakthrough successes, Roger Federer’s longevity and Novak Djokovic’s recent assaults on what is physically possible, it isn’t as if those of a rackets-based persuasion have been missing drama. Sadly however, the fourth contributor to this much-exalted ‘Golden Age’ of tennis has been reduced to posting messages of support for his various sporting compatriots on Facebook. Rafael Nadal has been conspicious by his absence since his remarkable second round defeat at Wimbledon.

In reality, that match against little-known Czech Lukas Rosol appears all the more fantastical when you realise that whatever occurred inside Nadal’s knees during the five-set epic has kept him out of of the Olympics, the US Open, and most recently the end-of-season ATP Tour finals event in London. The Spaniard is only 26, something which makes his seven French open titles seem even more sensational than they are, so there really shouldn’t be the lingering suspicion that this is a terminal thing. But for some intangible reason, there is.

Currently down to world number 4, those in the know have always harboured worries about his knees. His high-impact, high-athleticism style of game has always looked risky on the joints, and the tennis world spent a good time without Rafa following his 2009, and only, French Open defeat against Robin Soderling. However this time, the disconcerting thing has been that there has been an ever-moving yet vague return date, Nadal was even actually supposed to carry the Spanish flag during the Olympics. Facebook update after facebook update sounded positive for a while, but now given the disclosure that the injury is a partially torn patella tendon and “I’ll be back once the pain is gone,” (according to a link from his twitter feed), his return seems uncertain. Will we see him on the blue courts of Melbourne in January? It seems up in the air; he’s never been as imperious on hard courts as he has been on the red stuff of Rolland Garros, notwithstanding the tremendous contest he and Djokovic put on in Melbourne last January, so it wouldn’t be surprising to see his support team give the Australian Open a miss, especially if his form looks sketchy. Despite this, you can’t help but feel that the less time he’s on court the more we’re missing out on a man, who even having been genuinely record-shatteringly good, still retains stratospheric potential.

What does this mean for tennis then? After all Djokovic, Federer and Murray are all around? Plus a few young guns? This is all true, but there are certainly questions of the latter two big guns at least. Federer has already begun to garner age-related records, and he won’t go on forever, while Murray has, despite proving himself, yet to quite show the consistent brilliance required to put him permanently in the same bracket as the other three. (He most certainly can hit those heights over the next year or so though.) It’d be remiss to ignore the likes of Juan Martin Del Potro (himself having recovered from serious injury), but again he wouldn’t fill any Rafa shaped vacuum just yet. In an odd way, you could argue that this gap in the ‘magic four’ hegemony might allow a few breakthroughs, this is true, but until the likes of the prodigiously talented yet temperamental Bernard Tomic start beating the second tier likes of David Ferrer, Tomas Berdych and Jo-WIlfried Tsonga, they will have a lot to prove. Murray especially has the ability to go toe-to-toe with Djokovic that the sport needs, but another few years with Nadal and Federer too would allow this era to transcend the tennis court.

The sport still, in the opinion of this writer, needs Rafa’s spirit. He not only looks like the ultimate muscle-bound sportsman, but 99% of the time he has been part of an amazingly sporting contest. However, perhaps it is telling that pundits and analysts are no longer talking about him surpassing Federer’s Grand Slam tally. It just doesn’t look feasible anymore, and that is nothing but a great shame. Undoubtedly the man from Mallorca is one of the very best clay-court players to have served in anger, but two years ago it looked like he could have been so much more. Now all that we can do is cross our fingers and our toes (but be careful on those knees) and hope that whenever in 2013 Rafael Nadal does return from his extended fishing break, he’ll be as good as ever.

At Last…

A couple of hours ago I had an especially surreal little moment: At work, sorting out tables for the last time in the foreseeable future, ‘Time of Your Life’ by Greenday came over the speakers. I couldn’t contain myself and burst out laughing, at the sheer cliché factor. Well it was either that or the fact that it was fast closing in on eleven o’clock and I’d had less than five hours sleep in the last thirty-six, one of the two. Nonetheless I think that’s when it finally struck me what the hell is going on tomorrow, the whole going-to-Oxford thing.

In the form of a blog which I readily accept is pretty damn pretentious, I get the feeling that writing about the build-up to uni; something that a good number of the people (I hope!) who see this will have gone through (or will go through), seems to be the little bauble at the very top of the (very pretty) little pretention tree. The thing is though, all I really wanted to say was, simply, that it’s been a bloody good summer. If I get homesick or anything like that, I know I’ve got plenty of daft memories I’ll be able to summon, and not all of them involve drinking alcohol.

So, as I’m about to find myself as close to Hogwarts as is humanly possible (yes, I probably have to admit that seven year old me is rather chuffed at this development), I want to just say: So far, so good. I’ve never been one to ignore opportunities to be a sentimental pillock, but it’s hit me how lucky I have it to know the people that I do.

Where am I then? Well, I think it’s the beginning of Chapter 2. (Expect it to be serialised on here. I really do fancy myself a modern-day Dickens.)

PS. Blog re-styled, hatred welcome. 🙂

Limbo with Alcohol

Re; the title, it’s always a good idea, isn’t it?

At the start of the summer I had it in my had that I was going to update this blog with a fine piece of original writing at least every week. Needless to say that didn’t last very long, although I’m not entirely sure why. I’d blame it on being incredibly busy, rushed off my feet, in fact, but that’d be rather untrue. It’s not as if I’ve been short of topics to write about either, there’s a veritable stable of half-begun post-horses that have fallen by the wayside, for one reason or another. And anyone who’s spotted the little Hillsborough rant below, I’m not counting that; a spur of the moment, unchecked blur of injustice! 

So, I assume you’re all (yes I realise all is a slight exaggeration here) absolutely desperate to hear what I would have written? Of course you are, as much as this is akin to that awful moment during Who Wants To Be a Millionaire when Chris Tarrant rips up a check for sixty-four thousand pounds in front of your eyes.

I was very close to being very repetitive, actually, my next-to-last post had been about performance-enhancing drugs, and then the Lance Armstrong story broke. A tad cruel of the US Anti-doping Authority, I’d thought… Nonetheless it just occurred to me how much fall-out from the early part of the last decade still remains, when it comes to professional cycling. There is an endemic lack of trust in what you see before your eyes, and simply as a sports fan, that’s pretty painful to sit through. It’s certainly not over either, as much as it seemed like a rather perfectly plotted tragedy when the prototypical fighter, Armstrong, delivered his statement. There was no admission of guilt, simply an admission that he was backed into a corner, a last desperate attempt by the consumate may-aswell-have-been-a-statesman to prolong the siege of so many hearts and minds that he’d held for so long. In the end though, I think he simply chose to be tried by proxy, because his former manager and friend being found guilty, as may well happen (and although Armstrong’s climb-down suggests otherwise, it’s not impossible that Johan Bruyneel could be acquitted, I suppose), would mean very much the same as Lance going down himself.

Away from sport (yes I can hear the gasps), local events reignited a rather morbid curiosity of mine in Michael Gove’s ‘free schools’. Although of course it’s wrong to absolve the previous Labour government of any blame here. (Just this week Lord Adonis, the Labour peer and involved in education policy, described them as the future.) My thoughts are pretty succinct, I disagree with the idea of the British private education system on principle: Your wealth should not determine the quality of education you are given. (An episode of the BBC’s genealogy programme ‘Who Do You Think You Are?’ with the comedian Hugh Dennis illustrated this quite articulately, actually, as he finds out about the scholarship which allowed his grandfather to escape going down the mine in favour of  a secondary education, well worth checking out if you like that sort of thing.) The ‘sponsored’ system is however, if better for it’s more comprehensive and less selective nature, symptomatic of the growing trend seen in this government (predictably) to privatise things which ought not to be controlled by the whims of capitalism. The quality of an education should not depend on the ‘autonomy’ (a buzzword which all of the ‘delighted’ academy heads seemed scripted to parrot at regular intervals in the videos which are on the DfES website) of a governing body. I’m not entirely as au fait with this subject as I’d like, so I’m going to avoid parroting any ridiculous clichés at this moment in time, but when the government is talking about a single exam board and cosying up to the Pearson company, it becomes clear that there’s a worrying trend in education policy. Socially selective education isn’t the answer, but neither is commercialised education, and that’s the scary prospect.

The last real thing I’d half-heartedly written concerned, well, me. I was wondering why exactly I write such ludicrously pointless things as this, and still haven’t really hit upon an answer, to be blunt. But it sparked me thinking about being at a delicate little crossroads in life. I’m about to be off to university, and I’ve spent the last month or so cocooned in some bizarre form of limbo where there is a lot of alcohol, some fairly large sub-woofers, and a few gorillas playing chess in the Student Finance HQ (I think they’ve had me at checkmate for ages, although maybe they’ve just started toying with my pawns.) It’s been, to be glib, pretty damn cool, as is the thought of all the people I like to think of as friends crawling all over a map of the UK. (Although, there must be something attractive in Durham, god knows what, but they’re like moths to a flame, I swear I can slip a few more insect metaphors past you, too.) It’s an odd one, but being able to plot a penniless course through the next three years is fun, even if the aftermath promises to be ever more uncertain.

Oh, and I’m forgetting the dirty Harry Potter pick-up lines, they were the highlight, really. (Will try them on you on request and pending a sense of humour audit.)

Finally, I’m going to revive the Pretentious Poetry Corner in order to show you one last thing: Carol Ann Duffy writes on Hillsborough.

THE Cathedral bell, tolled, could never tell;

nor the Liver Birds, mute in their stone spell;

or the Mersey, though seagulls wailed, cursed, overhead,

in no language for the slandered dead…

not the raw, red throat of the Kop, keening,

or the cops’ words, censored of meaning;

not the clock, slow handclapping the coroner’s deadline,

or the memo to Thatcher, or the tabloid headline…

but fathers told of their daughters; the names of sons

on the lips of their mothers like prayers; lost ones

honoured for bitter years by orphan, cousin, wife –

not a matter of football, but of life.

Over this great city, light after long dark;

truth, the sweet silver song of the lark.

Hillsborough and Meaningless Apologies

“The Real Truth”. I suppose this is supposed to be good enough? I’m not even a Liverpool fan, never mind someone who’s been fighting for justice for twenty-three years, and I just don’t think it means much at all. In reality, the truth has been known for a very long time, and a perfunctory apology by an organisation which no doubt scarcely resembles what it was in 1989 doesn’t seem to go very far to righting any wrongs. A show of remorse, now, years after Mackenzie in particular refused to apologise, just doesn’t wash.

In fact, given the eery proliferation of mock-up Sun front pages yesterday, there’d have been an outcry if there hadn’t been a similar front page. The battle people have been facing hasn’t been about getting an apology from the Sun, albeit that was in all probability a very small part of it. What it has been about, is the fact that 96 people did not die because of any perceived idiocy. They died due to systemic failings in both the stadia used in sporting events, and the attitudes of the authorities, theoretically there to protect them. It’s just a shame that both the police and the government were infected by a vicious and classist snobbery about football fans, maybe they were deluded enough to think that they were protecting them from themselves. Of course this ended in tragedy.

Of course I’m not old enough to have lived through the dangers of being a football supporter in the 1980s, but what I do know is that today, we take for granted that we can go to a football stadium and watch a match, and come home again. (Can I make it clear that this is NOT a debate on the merits of terracing, it has been proven in places like Germany that there is such thing as ‘safe standing’, and that the post-Hillsborough debate focused so much on this seems an almost deliberate red herring, in hindsight.) There is a great article on nufc.com entitled “there but for the grace of God, go us” which I’d highly recommend.

To put the focus back on the Sun though, I’d be fascinated to see if the Hillsborough families could make a libel action stick.  Because in my opinion, criminal charges are surely the only way to ensure justice here. Had this sort of thing happened in a factory, there’d have been a charge of manslaughter for the high-ups. Remember, Hillsborough didn’t have an up-to-date safety certificate, paramedics were told to stop trying to save lives, the police were involved in forcing dangerous numbers of supporters into a confined area.

Also, there should be an investigation to try and bring charges to those involved in the cover-up, quite probably the biggest in British legal history, according to Michael Mansfield QC. It’s just a shame that twenty-three years has left many of the key players either dead or senile. (And that means you, Mrs. Thatcher.) How bloody convenient.

——————————————————————————————————————————————–

I’m not entirely convinced at the coherence of this, it probably wouldn’t survive a redraft, but felt there were a few things that needed to be said. The Sun appearing contrite now just isn’t good enough. It’s a glib apology designed to bury this as quickly as possible. The likes of Kelvin Mackenzie must be if not subject to the law, interrogated fully by a public platform. (Question Time would be good, for example.) This also highlights another failing in the British press, it’s accountability. (Interestingly it’s now become clear that several other newspapers received the same local press agency bulletin blaming the fans, but refused to run the story when it could not be corroborated. Given it’s untruth, obviously. http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/greenslade/2012/sep/12/hillsborough-disaster-daily-mirror )