An essay about Togetherness season 1 that I wrote a few months ago for something or other and which I’ve decided to re-home here. I really really liked it, and although this is about its first run, its second has been equally worth watching.
‘They seem like they’re getting there.’
Modern suburbia has never felt as stifling as it does in Mark and Jay Duplass’ Togetherness. The HBO series aired in the US at the beginning of 2015, and is a tight and poignant look at the roadblocks which undermine, perhaps fatally, our familial relationships.
So far, so much like any of a raft of recent American comedy-dramas, not least Lena Dunham’s own HBO vehicle Girls. (Dunham shares a long history with the Duplasses, too.) (Note: Amusingly, this was written before Netflix gave us Flaked, Love, or Master of None.) However in detailing the failing sexual chemistry and road-to-nowhere marriage of Mark Duplass’ Brett and the wonderful Melanie Lynskey’s Michelle, the series begins to do more than the likes of Girls, it manages to delve artfully into the psychological aspects of that age-old dream of many a couple: growing old together. For Brett and Michelle it has gradually become very hard indeed.
Steve Zissis as Brett’s best friend and wannabe actor Alex and Michelle’s sister Tina, played in equal parts manic and subdued by Amanda Peet, round out the show’s foursome of leads, with the latter couple’s romantic tension allowing Togetherness to play two relationships at entirely different stages against each other. Not that Alex and Tina are in a relationship, nor that a tired Will They/Won’t They dominated their storylines either. Instead they serve as more fleshed-out examples of the sublimated failings Brett and Michelle feel trapped by, too. Alex flailing for success that matches his own conception of himself—he’s a leading man not a chubby, funny sidekick— Tina just flailing.
Both are, in a convenient manner which reminds us that Togetherness is supposed to be a sitcom, staying at Brett and Michelle’s family home for the duration of the series. How they negotiate both this and a shared feeling of failure plays out alongside the show’s central marriage.
In truth Togetherness excels at depicting the dreary not-at-all-like-the-movies slice of American life once colonised exclusively by short story writers like Raymond Carver or Tobias Wolff. The Duplass brothers brought the traumas of the everyday— domestic boredom and unfulfilled hopes, joblessness, marital unhappiness, motherhood— to HBO. To quote the critic David Means on Carver, Togetherness offers ‘a sliver of some wider existence’. With help from Zissis who shares a creator credit, Duplass and Duplass tell the sort of story that is in itself a critique of more ornately plotted, structurally conceited sitcoms. Togetherness is about actual real life, they’re telling us, and that real life can be as compelling and moving as elaborate meet-cutes and seeing the same five people in a bar for ten years straight.
Instead Togetherness feels like a natural progression for the Duplass brothers. Known as pioneers in the so-called ‘Mumblecore’ indie movie scene, the stilted, honest dialogue between Brett and Michelle, Alex and Tina is perhaps the most obvious inherited trait. Films such as Safety Not Guaranteed, Hannah Takes the Stairs, and Your Sister’s Sister wedded themselves to a knowingly uncinematic manner, eschewing stylised plot or dialogue. Inability to communicate with those we care about became the central mumblecore ‘theme’, and Togetherness takes this conceit and, profoundly, runs with it. The series is full of “y’know”s, “dunno”s, “kinda”s and other carefully observed verbal signs of anxiety and confusion; this is about a critical lack of articulation. Not for nothing do the outsiders played by John Ortiz and Mary Steenburgen who Brett and Michelle respectively meet see them much more conversationally fluent.
At times though, Togetherness ditches the hyperrealism and ventures into trippy fantasy, and these elements are perhaps less well-handled than the show’s quieter moments, but the excursions Brett takes with self-avowedly “weird” Linda during episodes six and seven allow the Duplass brothers to engage with the crippling claustrophobia of the too-full home at Togetherness’ heart. This aspect of the plot could, bizarrely be described by saying that Brett finds a hippy hiding in a bush who helps give his self-brutalising anxiety an outlet. Quite literally, in one scene Mark Duplass and the delicately off-kilter Mary Steenburgen spend a magic mushroom-induced moment screaming into the Californian wilderness. If that sounds like a scene from a different television show, it is because it feels that way. Togetherness calculatedly transforms from an awkward and grindingly intimate piece into something which feels briefly like an agoraphobic’s worst nightmare. For Brett though, this utter freedom is necessary, and the production team don’t shy away from presenting what comes perilously close to a full-blown breakdown.
The drug induced mania then reaches its climax in devastating fashion, with Mark Duplass at his quiet best returning to his character’s family home wearing a too-short ladies dressing gown that’s entirely inappropriate for the children’s party he finds himself in the middle of. The final episode sees Brett on a more even keel, mostly thanks to touching moments of connection with his five-year old daughter, and an about-to-be-successful Alex, but the disjunction between Brett and his wife will remain, a poignant and truthful-to-life barrier to happiness.
And on the other side of this marital equation Lynskey shines. As vibrant as Zizzis, Dupass, and Peet are, she is the real star of Togetherness. Facially her ability to express how utterly adrift she feels from her husband is time and again the most haunting aspect of this show, particularly as the series draws to a close and her interactions, and instant chemistry with the dashing charter-school pioneer David begins to show. Rarely does fiction —on TV, film or in books— present impending adultery as so understandable.
From being caught during an awkward attempt at Fifty Shades-inspired masturbation, complete with repurposed clothes pegs as nipple clamps to her painfully rebuffed go at a little BDSM experimentation with her husband, scenes that could be cheaply salacious and erotic, are instead undercut by a subtle but extreme despair. Lynskey’s Michelle is wounded by a certain dreary monotony, by having given up her life for her family and seeing herself growing older but no happier. In her early-to-mid thirties she’s become all but sexually incompatible with a husband who has begun to spin off into his own confused orbit. An early episode sees her blow-off a glitzy engagement (Brett works as a sound engineer on a film) to just wander. Minutes later she ends up giving a group of teenagers cigarettes and revelling in the fact that they see her a sexy older woman, revelling in being found interesting and not being weighed down by her husband or family.
The final episode of the show’s first run takes pains to demonstrate that this is no staid rom-com. As James Blake’s haunting ‘The Wilhelm Scream’ lets us know that Michelle, having saved the charter school project is “falling”, the show-runners tease the viewer with a pair of classic tropes, the timely arrival and the declaration of love. In Togetherness though, neither work, and Alex will make peace with his acting success rather than his romantic glory, while a second series will have to handle a whole barrow of unanswered questions about Brett and Michelle. The Duplasses and Zissis have not made this easy for their audience, but my god they’ve made it real.
A few months before Togetherness premiered, Richard Linklater’s Boyhood was the talk of the entertainment world with it documentary-esque portrayal of the trials and tribulations which make up ordinary life. Togetherness does something similar but without the fad of having filmed for twelve years. Life doesn’t necessarily lend itself to what we usually conceive of ‘drama’ or ‘plot’, but if you go looking for poignancy and humour in the banal and the domestic, plot and drama can make themselves known. This is the thesis at the heart of Togetherness, and it is one that the show makes good on. It illustrates the often painful banality of normal life.
A couple has come apart at the seams, and they explain the show pretty well themselves: Michelle’s “what is going on with you? What is going on?” finds Brett in his incongruent —and to her offensive— dressing gown reply, “You were having a great time, until I turned up.” They are an example of the opposite of togetherness, exemplary of the perils of not working at one’s domestic life and falling into stagnant patterns instead. Togetherness is tragicomedy really, an exploration of how humans can possibly survive bound too-tightly to another. Tina is this idea taken to a logical conclusion too, sublimating herself in a loveless relationship because she can’t face the risk of someone getting too close, and in this way her character is the saddest, especially in a finale which expresses hope for each of the other leads.
A TV show about an unyielding slide towards adultery, played out largely in quiet conversations and with subtle musical cues (James Blake excepted) shouldn’t have worked. However Togetherness pulls together the threads of the Duplass brother’s careers alongside some revelatory performances from Lynskey and Zissis to wonderful effect. This subtle, mournful show captures life’s nasty little ironies like nothing I can remember.




